top of page

FAHM Film Review: A Filipinx Critique of the Military-Sex Complex

Oct 26, 2023
6 min read


What role did the US have in the Philippine Diaspora?


Hello everyone and Happy Fil-Am History Month! As promised we at the Peminist Team of Stacey’s Corner have prepared a review of Philippine and Fil-Am cinema to celebrate Fil-Am History Month. The following films we’ll explore for this post include: Markova: Comfort Gay (2000), directed by Gil Portes and Call Her Ganda (2018), directed by P.J. Raval. These two films in the list are thematically connected, as they all grapple with the sexual, gendered, and racial legacies caused by western colonialism.


You might notice how some films have more in common with each other than others. For example, Markova: Comfort Gay and Call Her Ganda both take place in the Philippines, and centers around the lived realities of real life LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o individuals who experience sexual and gendered-based colonial violence under military occupation. Tragically, their stories are met with systemic erasure, because their intersecting identities as LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o people defy rigid and pre-existing categories.


When marginalized groups do speak, it is important to note how they use terminology and language to highlight their experiences. Thus for this film review post, we will address why such terminology from the community is a form of resistance to systematic erasure borne from imperialist practices and culture.




Markova: Comfort Gay (2000). Directed by Gil Portes (1h 37m)


TW: graphic content related to sexual violence, review covers graphic content related to sexual abuse and violence


Markova: Comfort Gay is a biographical film loosely based on the life of Walter Dempster Jr., also known as Walterina Markova. Markova self identified as a “comfort gay”. The name takes inspiration from “comfort women,” referring to the women and girls who were kidnapped and brutally coerced as sexual slaves by the Imperial Japanese Army during World War II. Philippines’ patriarchal values and beliefs, rooted in Spanish colonialism, facilitated a culture of silence that forced many Filipina girls and women to hide their traumatic abuse at the hands of “Japan's sexual slavery system” out of feelings of internalized shame (McCarthy, “Why These World War II Sex Slaves Are Still Demanding Justice”, 6). It was not until decades later when elderly women began to tell their stories. This ultimately encouraged Markova to recount his experience as part of a dance troupe during World War II. He and his barkada (friends) who were part of this troupe were subjected to sex slavery very similar to “comfort women.”


For many elderly Filipina women or lolas (grandmothers), they argued that “survivors of the wartime female slavery system” be used (McCarthy, “Why These World War II Sex Slaves Are Still Demanding Justice”, 6) rather than the term “comfort women.” It is important to note that these conversations may have not been as widely circulated around the time that Markova was alive, and that his use of “comfort gay” was the best available language during the time to describe his lived realities.


Terminology continues to be a prevalent theme throughout the movie! For many marginalized groups like LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o folks, the purpose of terminology is to accurately reflect lived realities, which aids in materially changing their lives for the better. However, in Markova’s case, terminology actually prevented others from understanding and empathizing with his struggles. Why is that? Maybe we get a glimpse of these dynamics when the journalist left and Markova hurled a string of terms at younger photographs of himself:


“Pambabae! Pede Boy! Bakla! Badeng! Gay! You’re only trying to be true to yourself! But all they see is a sham.” (Markova, 01:30:53).


Filipino words like bakla and badeng in this film are used interchangeably with gay. However, as the term Filipinx reveals, terminology is borne from specific social, cultural, political and historical context. According to scholars like Martin Manalansan, “Bakla is the Tagalog term that encompasses homosexuality, hermaphroditism, cross-dressing, and effeminacy. One of the bakla’s singular attributes is a sense of self entrenched in the process of transformation” (Manalansan, Global Divas, ix). Transformation does not necessarily take precedence under the term gay, at least not in the same way it does under bakla. The common tendency to conflate bakla and badeng with gay potentially views gender and sexuality through a western frameworks, and consequently erases very important nuances from the lived realities of people like Markova.


At the end of the film, Markova is seen dancing alone in women’s dress and makeup. As they danced, younger versions of himself emerged and joined him. It was through an act of resistance, his dance, that he could communicate how he survived, despite imperialist-homophobic sentiments and culture attempting to suppress, shame, and erase his existence. This scene highlighted how he was the only performer left amongst his dance troupe to survive, and pass down these histories. This scene also emotionally reveals what words and terminology oftentimes cannot express; for Markova, his solo dance provided him an outlet to courageously and lovingly name himself, name his role and his existence in history as someone contributing to a larger movement of being able to claim and define Filipinx.


Call Her Ganda (2018). Directed by PJ Raval (1h 33m)



Jennifer Laude was a 26 year old transgender Filipinx/a who was murdered by an American marine, Joseph Scott Pemberton, in 2014. Laude’s tragic and untimely death resonates with the experiences of many LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o folks who are viewed and treated as second class citizens. Similar to Markova, Laude is treated publicly as an unreliable narrator of her own lived experiences, partly due to her marginalized status. Her family and her fiance resist the vicious media attacks against her character for her. The legacy that American imperialism and colonialism has left on the Philippines is seen in the homophobic and transphobic language used against Laude. Similar to the struggles that Markova faced in naming themselves into history, Laude, even in death, suffered from the public who misremembered and vilified her. In Raval’s documentary Call Her Ganda multiple people who cared for Laude, and knew her personally, spoke about her experience so that the public, both at a domestic and international level, could empathize and understand the racialized and sexualized violence committed against her.


Laude’s death mobilized a transgender movement in the Philippines, and ignited heated debates about the “sovereignty” of the Philippines that still operates as a “neo-colony” under US military occupation (00:19:01). Laude’s story and stories similar to hers dramatically unsettled the political and cultural landscape of the Philippines, because it revealed how violence inflicted upon Filipinx/a/o citizens is formally institutionalized through Philippine-American legislation. Specifically, legislation like the VFA (visiting forces agreement). The VFA protects US military agents, like the marine who killed Laude, if they commit a crime in the Philippines and/or against Filipinx/a/o citizens. These laws reflect the asymmetrical power relations between America and the Philippines, and obviously stems from decades of colonialism and imperialism.


Laude’s death is also evidence that popular narratives like American exceptionalism and benevolent assimilation—or the idea that America is a force for global good that helps disenfranchised countries and folks to achieve prosperity through teaching them western ideology—are instruments to assert dominance. The United States depends on such narratives to justify its hold on the Philippines, and to absolve any accountability when it inflicts harm against Filipinx/a/o citizens. How can the United States be the perpetrators of violence when it’s known globally as a beacon of democracy?



Solidarity: International Support for Jennifer Laude


Raval’s film showcases how Laude’s lived experience and tragic death proves how the United States is in fact the perpetrator of harm while also actively benefiting from such harm. For instance, the documentary reveals how transgender women face disproportionate amount of gender-based sexual violence at the hands of the US military as sex workers. But, according to scholars like Paul A. Kramer, the United States and the US military operates under a “military-sexual complex” that depends on “[securing] its male soldiers sexual access” to Filipina women (Kramer, “The Military-Sexual Complex, 1).

Like Markova, Laude was a victim of the military-sexual complex, but where they diverged was that Laude existed in a time where there was language to help her identify a common enemy that harmed LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o folks. This language emerged through a history of survivors like the “comfort woman” and “comfort gay” alongside the international Filipinx/a/o LGBTQIA+ community who collectively resisted against these militant colonial and imperial forces.


Concluding on a Reflection


Markova: Comfort Gay and Call Her Ganda are both in continuing conversation with each other. What these two films showcase is that the Filipinx/a/o community, the LGBTQIA+ community, has always developed movements and language to name their oppressors and their experiences. Present-day harm inflicted upon LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o people also includes erasure, especially as it pertains to mainstream representation about the Fil-Am and Filipinx community. But, whatever rare representation there is of LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o people, it is oftentimes inaccurate and dehumanizing. Negative representation seeps into real life and results in material violence against LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o people and communities. To combat the one-dimensional depictions that undermine LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o self-determination, the Peminist Team of Stacey’s Corner will continue to present a collection of queer films that provide humanizing and intersectional portrayals of Filipinx people within the homeland and within the Fil-Am diaspora. Look out for our next and last post to celebrate Fil-Am History Month next week where we will review Documented and Lingua Franca.


Ingat fellow readers and peminist wanderers.



Comments


IMG_3279.jpeg

Hi, thanks for stopping by!

Hello! My name is Dr. Stacey Anne Baterina Salinas! I hope you continue to follow me on my journey in blogging and growing into my thirties and career as a new professor!

Let the posts
come to you.

Thanks for submitting!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Contact Me

Thank You for Contacting Me!

© 2021 Stacey's Corner: Peminist Millenial Thoughts. All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page