top of page

A Holiday Review of Philippine Teleseryes: Culinary Care Work as Joyful Resistance in Replacing Chef Chico

Jan 7, 2024
11 min read

Greetings fellow p/feminist wanderers and readers! We hope you and everyone around you are doing well. This blog post marks the beginning of 2024 (Yay!), and the end of our two-part series where we use Replacing Chef Chico (2023) as a point of pop cultural reference. The last time we tsismised (gossiped; exchanged community knowledge), we explored how racialized and gendered hierarchies have infiltrated the broader Filipinx/a/o community, particularly through cultural traditions that have shaped our Philippine cuisine. These racialized and gendered hierarchies consequently create misogynistic and patriarchal environments and mindsets, contributing to a culture where many Filipinas, despite their essential roles as cultural caregivers and providers, are driven away from, if not denied, having a respected seat at our family dinner table.


Ayo kabalak! (Don’t worry!) Fortunately for us in the community the ingenuity and resourcefulness of Filipinas never ceases to stop. If you’ve ever been to a Filipinx/a/o Christmas and/or New Years party, you know that quintessential to that family experience is a tita (aunt) and/or ate (older sister) whipping out delicious food while also dealing some juicy tsismis as her way of “catching up” with and bringing family together. Filipinas therefore create the tastiest meals even as the kitchen becomes a pressure cooker! By using a critical Filipinx lens, we can observe how Filipinas have reclaimed domestic care, like cooking, to foster community joy, humor, and solidarity during challenging times in Philippine history. Feel free to gather around as we tsismis about the ways in which Filipinas have always resisted racialized and gendered hierarchies, even amidst misogynistic and patriarchal forces that dismiss their presence at the dinner table, to cook for and house their chosen families.

Creating Paksiw from Lechon Scraps: Filipinas Reclaim Cookbooks and Cuisine



Misogynistic and patriarchal forces rooted in western colonialism have forced many Filipinas away from the community dinner table. Especially, when such forces utilize cultural forms of knowledge production, like cookbooks and cuisine, to validate a culture where Filipina women are treated as second class citizens. However, as René Alexander D. Orquiza also emphasizes in Taste of Control, Filipinas during the early 20th century reclaimed their community knowledge by way of preserving their heritage and cultural insight through traditional, and Indigenous, Philippine cuisine.


Filipinas like Sophia Reyes de Veyra and Maria Paz Zamora Mascunana wrote Everyday Cookery for the Home (1933), because they “envisioned food as an effective tool for Filipina women to assert their identity and importance in the rapidly changing Philippine society,” (Orquiza, Taste of Control, 92). The duo thereby wielded Filipinx/a/o cuisine as a form of cultural resistance against American colonialism that was erasing Filipinx/a/o culture, history, and people by forcing Filipinos to take on culinary preferences and foodstuffs by eliminating or destroying the natural wildlife and crops, forcing young Filipinas to learn American cooking as part of their Thomasite education, and transforming the Philippine food economy by introducing American canned goods.


Filipina women at the center of the domestic cultural front, like Sophia Reyes de Veyra and Paz Zamora Mascunana, understood the visible and invisible ways that America attempted to overtake and erase the cultural significance and community practices of their new colonial territories and its peoples. Veyra and Mascunana wrote Everyday Cookery as “a reaction to the repeated dismissal of Filipina cuisine by American reformers” (Orquiza, Taste of Control, 91). The duo refused to succumb to racialized and gendered hierarchies that categorized Filipinx/a/o cuisine, culture, and people as racial inferiors, so the two “wrote the first cookbook of the American Period that celebrated indigenous culinary tradition” (Orquiza, Taste of Control, 91). By implementing, innovating, and illustrating culinary mastery of native Filipinx/a/o ingredients within their recipes, both proved through food that Filipinx/a/o cuisine and culture could go toe to toe against American palates (Orquiza, Taste of Control, 101). Everyday Cookery is, in short, a wonderful example of how “restoring dignity to Filipino cooking” could also restore dignity to Filipina/x people, practices, and ways of life which does not conform to white supremacist and patriarchal gender norms reaffirmed by American occupation (Orquiza, Taste of Control, 92).

Cup of Kapwa for the Road?


Everyday Cookery proved that food could be an effective form of cultural resistance that brought back Filipina/x people who have been systematically and institutionally cast away back to the dinner table. Veyra and Mascunana were thereby practicing kapwa. As defined by Filipina/o scholar activist, Raju Kahaku Singh DeSai, kapwa is “the core value of Filipina/o indigenous psychology that emphasizes our interrelatedness with one another (DeSai, “Critical Kapwa,” 34). DeSai’s research interest in Philippine/Filipino American Studies reveals how the ongoing systemic issues that plagues the Filipinx/a/o community originates from the compounding effects of Spanish and American colonialism (DeSai, “Critical Kapwa,” 35). Furthermore, these systemic issues are also intentionally created to separate and disconnect many of us from our own Filipinx/a/o community.


DeSai consequently proposes Critical Kapwa Pedagogy as a means to heal community trauma by “[including] all perspectives” to create connections between “one another, to our families, to our history, and our ancestors” (DeSai, “Critical Kapwa,” 35). Food provides an outlet to practice kapwa, because it is a material remnant that embodies a shared Filipinx/a/o history that emotionally tethers us together. Other Filipinas who illustrate kapwa, besides Veyra and Mascunana, is Replacing Chef Chico’s sous chef: Ellen.

Chico’s Kitchen…


Ellen can be interpreted as a character that practices kapwa. Arguably, it is what gravitates her to Hain and Chico in the first place. As Chico puts it:


“Look, Hain, is not about money. We’re about every guest’s story. The only

degustation restaurant that personalizes the menu based on our guests’

unique story and personality, even going out of our way to interview them,

deserves to have a spot on that fucking list.” (Chico, “Episode 1,” 00:07:02)


Hain’s culinary values, as reflected through their unique menu, are responding to deeper legacies of dual colonialism that systematically erased Filipinx/a/o identities, histories, and peoples. For example, social movements and political policies of “benevolent assimilation” during the American Period attempted to establish racialized and gender hierarchy by categorizing Filipinx/a cultural practices as inherently inferior (Orquiza, “Taste of Control,” 89). Cultural practices that were considered racially inferior in comparison to western cultural practices included food and cuisine. By establishing a racialized and gendered hierarchy, America’s colonial oversight justified the assimilation and consequent erasure of Filipinx/a/o identities, histories, people, and cultural practices as racial “uplift” (Orquiza, “Taste of Control,” 83). For Hain, personalized menus that fit the emotional and cultural narratives of their guests is an emotionally charged art of resistance to the common understanding that Filipinx/a/o “stor[ies] and personalit[ies]” have indeed been so severely invisibilized due to intense collective colonial erasure and neglect. The Hain restaurant is in turn attempting to convey these hidden Filipinx/a/o “stor[ies] and personalit[ies]” that have been systemically and institutionally erased using Filipinx/a/o cuisine.


Unfortunately, racialized and gendered hierarchies have seeped into the Filipinx/a/o culinary world influencing characters like Chico. Hain’s value system is certainly admirable, but at the hands of Chico, the execution of these values in their cooking and dialogue is clearly flawed and counterintuitive. Chico inflicts misogynistic tendencies and allows cis-heteropatriarchal anxieties to fester in his own kitchen. To protect his own ego/machismo (male chauvinism) and his position at the top of the kitchen food chain, Chico is willing to forgo any form of care work in the kitchen which is hypocritical to the culinary care work he tries to provide his guests. By doing so, he feeds into the same practices that uphold patriarchal colonial structures of gendered violence. For example, one of the main story lines which follows the entirety of Replacing Chef Chico is the pursuit of Hain being recognized in the ranking lineup of “Asia’s Best of the Best”; a prestigious culinary list that would provide the restaurant much needed recognition within the Philippine and broader Asian culinary scene. Chico assumes that the anonymous culinary critic representing Asia’s Best of the Best to assess their food would be “a male Caucasian in his 40s” (Chico, “Episode 6”, 00:03:10). The food critic, however, is later identified as a Filipina who provides a glowing review of Ellen rather than Chico.


Instead of celebrating Ellen for her recent accomplishment, Chico accuses Ellen of sleeping with the food critic to get such a review (Chico, “Episode 7”, 00:27:00). Chico weaponizes patriarchal and misogynistic anger to mask his jealousy, therefore reaffirming racialized and gendered hierarchies meant to subordinate and invisibilize Filipinas. It also illustrates how racialized and gendered hierarchies operate by creating unneeded competition within the Filipinx/a/o community that we all have felt at one point in our lives or another that speaks to sowing division to keep us separated.

Ellen’s Kitchen!


When Ellen successfully becomes head chef we begin to see this culture of cis-heteropatriarchal and misogynistic anger dissipate. Hain’s attempts to create Filipinx/a/o cuisine that reflects every “guests’ unique story and personality” clearly aligns with Ellen’s own value system surrounding food. Although she uses Chico’s language to explain how “Here at Hain, we don’t simply serve food. We tailor it to your unique story,” (Ellen, “Episode 6,” 00:08:36) what differentiates Ellen’s culinary care work from Chico’s is that she centers Filipinx/a/o people, communities, and connections at the forefront when creating food.


As the only lead Filipina woman in the kitchen staff, Ellen understands the social isolation and the unfair division of affective and physical labor when attempting to navigate misogynistic culinary culture. Nonetheless, Ellen refuses to replicate the same misogynist and cis-heteropatriarchal practices that have hurt her when she takes over in the kitchen.


“I was starting to love being head chef. Really, a female head chef, you

know? Who was followed and respected, and being listened to by the male

chefs here. It seemed impossible once. This kitchen became everything I

wanted it to be. Relaxed but still efficient. Light but also very inspiring.”

(Replacing Chef Chico, “Episode 6,” 00:15:27)


Such a statement reveals how Ellen consciously co-created a kitchen culture where everyone’s “unique stor[ies] and personalit[ies]” are indeed accepted and heard at the table.


Ellen ultimately rejects the racialized and gendered hierarchies designed by western colonial forces to divide the Filipinx/a/o community. She instead follows in the footsteps of past Filipina culinary experts like Veyra and Mascunana who use Filipinx/a/o cuisine as a cultural pathway, shared history, and emotional tether to keep Filipinx/a/o people together, creating more opportunities for meaningful connections. In other words, Ellen throughout the series practices kapwa by using Filipinx/a/o cuisine as a form of community care work that bridges Filipinx/a/o people from all walks of life together.

Home for the Holidays


Ellen’s practice of culinary kapwa is best illustrated in the seventh episode of Replacing Chef Chico. A Filipinx gay couple, Vince and Rick, are the main guests that struggle to find a seat at their own family dinner table. Their struggle speaks to how dual western colonialism has marginalized queer Filipinx people based on their non cis-heterosexual identities. In response to these systemic issues, the couple requested a seventeen course meal for their ceremonial wedding dinner which includes dishes like dinakdakan (Ilocano delicacy consisting of pork, spices, and vegetables) empanadas.


When giving their thanks for the dinakdakan empanadas, the couple reveals the multi-layered significance of the dish for them:


“Thank you for this and for honoring our request for dinakdakan empanadas.

I just had a taste and it’s heavenly! Just perfect! We’re from the northern

region and our guests’ favorite food is dinakdakan. And I’m sure it’s going to

be delicious, especially wrapped in an empanada shell. We’re sure it’s the

dinakdakan we grew up with…It’s not easy. Although it’s been so many

years, Vince’s family won’t acknowledge me.” (Rick, “Episode 7”, 00:13:14)


As revealed through Rick’s statement, many queer Filipinx/a/o people have been dispossessed from their homes and/or biological families. Without any other means to access home, food for Vince and Rick invokes an emotional attachment to their Ilokana/o origins.


Vince and Rick may be fictional characters, but their struggles are too commonplace amongst the queer Filipinx/a/o community. Cis-heteronormative and patriarchal gender constructs rooted in western colonialism still underpins Filipinx/a/o culture, resulting in many queer Filipinx/a/o people being driven away from their original homes, families, and communities. For example, Hannah Reyes Morales provides an account of the Golden Gays; a community of elderly gay men or lolas (grandmothers) who “have lived together for decades in the Philippines, hosting shows and pageant performances on the weekends to make ends meet” (Morales, “The ‘Golden Gays’ Return to the Stage in the Philippines”). The Golden Gays began in the 1970s as a shelter created by Manila councilman and AIDS activist, Panfilo Cagoco Justo (Justo Justo), which served as a safe communal space away from Filipino cis-heteronormativity, machismo, and homophobia.


Tragically, Justo’s passing in 2012 forced many lolas to return back to the street. According to LGBTQ community organizer, Mrs. Habijan, homelessness is a prevalent systemic issue amongst the queer Filipinx/a/o community:


“They were thrown out of the house by the family of Justo, and I guess what

sparked among the community through that kind of story is the shared

experience of being disowned, of being thrown out of a home that you want

for yourself…We know what it’s like to be rejected. We know what it’s like to

be disowned. We know the fear of being thrown out of our own homes.”

(Morales, “The ‘Golden Gays’ Return to the Stage in the Philippines”)


The physical and emotional displacement the Golden Gays experience is ultimately a shared experience that is common across the queer Filipinx/a/o community, as represented through characters like Vince and Rick.


Gayatri Gopinath’s work can better describe the fraught relationship that queer people of color have with finding and being at “home”. Gopinath, as a scholar of Social and Cultural Analysis, integrates film, literature, and social science to reveal how romanticized notions of home crumble when queer people of color from South Asian diasporas are centered. According to Gopinath in Queer Diasporas and South Asian Public Cultures, “home for a queer diasporic subject becomes not only that which ‘we cannot not want’ but also that which we cannot and could never have” due to histories of colonial violence that implemented cis-heteronormative gender expectations (73). Through Ellen’s culinary care work, she helps Vince and Rick feel welcome to a home they were once denied and provides each of them a seat at the family table by creating dinakdakan empanadas.


As a Filipina, Ellen has personal experience in how racialized and gendered hierarchies weaponize heterosexism and patriarchy to isolate certain Filipinx/a/o people. Instead of reaffirming these hierarchies, Ellen puts kapwa into action by feeding people who have been and still are similarly victimized by these same oppressive systems. As the culinary critic who praised Ellen stated:


“And it’s thanks to female chefs like chef Ellen, who have endured

harassment, the misogynistic culture, and habit of ignoring women’s

achievements in culinary cuisine…There was love in every dish, and it was

Chef Ella’s heart beating through and through.” (Replacing Chef Chico,

“Episode 7”, 00:25:32)


Filipinas like Ellen, Veyra, and Mascunana therefore wield their cultural culinary care work to subvert the submissive domestic care roles that western (neo)colonial forces have imposed upon Filipinas. Filipinas as resistance fighters, in this case as culinary artisans, can show us other ways to rebuild and love our people and communities; to such an extent that they have radically transformed the gendered skillsets expected as purely domestic care. By offering cultural food as storytelling, Ellen’s method of kapwa shows us how we can still nourish and grow our Filipinx/a/o communities.

Conclusion


As we wrap up our holiday series of Replacing Chef Chico, we also want to congratulate our fellow p/feminist readers and wanderers for seeing the holiday season through! The holidays for many of us in the Filipinx/a/o community means experiencing emotional whiplash as family and unspoken legacies of colonial trauma converge. We hope that this blog post provides some sense of relief and an opportunity for self-reflection. Ellen herself [Spoilers!] does not end her story professionally and romantically with Chico. A reminder that we have a choice with who we sit at the table with.


It is also completely understandable that amidst the familial conflict and community chaos during this holiday season, that being with family still brings you that nostalgic feeling of belonging. If so, we hope that when you dive into your pork sinigang, tinolang manok, and pancit that you do feel that Filipinx/a/o food can still help us to communicate that wish and desire to see the Filipinx/a/o community grow; where through healthier dialogue over shared food can spark transformations and opportunities where we are able to convey the feelings and ideas that we otherwise have difficulty expressing due to histories of colonial trauma that has tried to keep us apart.


Ingat fellow readers and peminist wanderers.


 
 
 

Comments


IMG_3279.jpeg

Hi, thanks for stopping by!

Hello! My name is Dr. Stacey Anne Baterina Salinas! I hope you continue to follow me on my journey in blogging and growing into my thirties and career as a new professor!

Let the posts
come to you.

Thanks for submitting!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Contact Me

Thank You for Contacting Me!

© 2021 Stacey's Corner: Peminist Millenial Thoughts. All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page