Pinayist Reflections on Pedagogy: Re-Learning the Purpose of the Classroom In the Face of New Age Fascism

Two whirlwind years have passed since I embarked on this journey into a career that required 9 years of graduate school work. The four self imposed walls of graduate school felt at times like an unforgiving escape room. Throughout both my most dreadful and fondest memories, the critical learning-work seemed repetitive, hopeless, invigorating, challenging, and galvanizing all at the same time. Accomplishing some of the most unforgiving circumstances of the paths leading to this career as a professor, I thought naively that the worst was over.
Two years after leaving the Ivory Tower, I felt I had traveled a comfortable enough distance away from the things that motivated my anxiety and insecurities.
But two years of teaching at the community college setting, as soon as I felt myself finally understanding the workflow of my teaching profession and balancing the writing act as an academic, the world beneath our feet that had already been crumbling since the pandemic, seems to have collapsed fully and swallowed us whole.
Two years of teaching American history and never did I think my everyday of teaching the timeline of the sins and falsehoods of American nationalism would fall in line and match the pace of our current timeline of the alt-right and its cronies repeating the same language and fascist actions of the past.
The last year in the classroom served as my crystal ball foreshadowing what horrors were waiting for us in this new age of fascism. I covered topics familiar to the Gilded Age: new-money industrialists, gluttonous trusts and robber barons whose dollars ran congress and were responsible for murdering and pillaging Indigenous lands, genocidal acts opted as the go-to option for settler-colonizing regimes, and the regular phenomenon of starving the overworked poor. I covered xenophobic immigration policies during the 1880s-1930s that scapegoated "foreigners" and jailed, murdered, and deported BIPOC families seeing them as the reasons for America's economic failures. I showed case studies of the horrors of neo-colonial mutilation and the taking of blood and flesh extracted for the sake of empire as daily spectacles under the might of American neo-imperialism as its ever growing military industrial complex continued to consume the world from the mid to late twentieth century.
Discussing such heavy topics, and then connecting the past to the present after every lecture, scarily made me consider more often than before that the most corny and truest phrase historians know by heart was coming to fruition in another ugly cycle before us:
“Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”
– George Santayana
Many students "understood the assignment" and were concerned as to how the past indeed mirrors our current circumstances and have extended into our ever growing societal ills at present. But recently, what I found the most alarming was coming from other young voices who were quite the opposite in their engagement with the course topics. Instead there was a growing number of apathetic voices. Some even argued that the classroom and history as a field should not discuss politics, nor ever be "political" - whatever that means.
In many of these scenarios, I had to define terms we take for granted in order to help the class deconstruct these sentiments that argued history is objective and thus apolitical. Almost to an eerie now familiar rhythm, I can recount my definition of politics and history at the drop of a dime because of how often I have had these scenarios play out in the physical and virtual classroom.
Politics are about understanding how power operates within a functioning society, and how policies that majorities craft and vote on affect and inform who has power and who does not; or in other words, politics is a process of crafting legal means to state and justifying who is deserving of living fully and freely and who is not. History is a field that explores and explains change over time; why things happened in the ways that they did and who was affected and how. Therefore one could argue American history is one way to storytell about how America came into power and crafted policies to maintain that power struggle for the status quo. With the additional frameworks of Ethnic and Gender Studies superimposed on historical narratives, we then conclude with asking students to then consider, "Why and how does this information still carry weight and what can we do about it?"
Over the past year, I came across more voices that argued that the knowledge provided in Humanities and Social Science classes were not "useful" and that weekly readings and writing exercises were "pointless and a waste of time because they were busy-work."
On more than a handful of occasions of reading emails and reading responses, I came across more young voices that outright argued "these topics [at the time we were covering the civil rights movement(s)] don't matter and don't affect me, so why should I care?" One of the most alarming comments I read was one student arguing that white supremacists and domestic terrorists "did some bad things, but their bad actions also made it possible for good things to happen, like the civil rights movement." To make matters worse, the more apathy I found in the physical and virtual classrooms, the more I noticed an uptick in the over indulgence and abuse of AI being used for class assignments to write these comments and critiques.
Thus, this past year of my career, I found myself feeling somewhat dejected. I began to notice that fascist phrases and attitudes outside of the classroom were making their way into the classroom. With this uptick of incel and TERF behavior being voiced in the classroom and virtually through the class forums, I found myself losing patience and faith in humanity on more than one occasion. To make matters worse, students were using AI to craft such scornful, misinformed, and uncaring nonsense. Such words written by some alternate non-human interface, made their words all the more unfeeling, and thus showcasing how careless we have become with our misplaced hate, aggression, apathy, and overall willingness to allow ourselves to become desensitized and detached to the experiences and histories of others.
So where to go from here and how to pick up my mood for the upcoming school year and life in general as we see democracy, critical thinking, and compassion fizzle into a fever dream?

Reflecting on how I can continue to grow as a scholar-activist always requires me to work on my pedagogy. The goal of an educator is to provide knowledge that helps their students gain new skills and perspectives. With their new skills in hand, learners will be able to have a better sense of the world and consider their potential place in it. With that in mind, my questions as of recent included: How do you muster the emotional energy to continue to teach in the face of rising apathetic audiences? Such emotional questions led me to balance my emotions by answering intellectual queries thus reminding me to reflect on 1. what is the purpose of the fields I work in and 2. why did I want to teach History and Ethnic Studies in the first place?
For me, as corny as it may seem, history has always served as a window into the past and provided me with multiple visuals and written timelines as to how our current socio-political and economic dynamics and circumstances came to be. Listening to, reading about, and writing reflectively on the past are critical steps to knowing how to address and resolve out current predicaments. As an Ethnic Studies scholar-activist, listening to the experiences of our elders, I learned how they navigated and challenged oppression and discrimination. Both fields inadvertently allowed me to be more observant, reflective, and more patient in learning from others because both fields taken together require one to actively and regularly listen to the experiences of others.
In this intellectual and emotional exercise of reflecting on the purpose of my career as it is being attacked and defunded, I came across the writings of John Dewey (American philosopher and educator, 1859-1952) on why we must value healthy forms of communication. For Dewey, a free democratic social life provided across generations requires an education that instills habits that inform the fabric of democratic culture. The habit in particular that an education must provide is how and why as human beings, we practice and make regular healthy dialogue- communication therefore is essential to, as Dewey places it, "essential to cultivating sympathy, intelligence, and creativity" in the face of fascist takeovers.
One cannot share in intercourse with others without learning—without getting a broader point of view and perceiving things of which one would otherwise be ignorant.”
-John Dewey
Such transformative yet simple pedagogy, one that advocates for conversation and thoughtful dialogue reminded me of one of the core tenets or considerations for Pinayist and peminist praxis. Pinayists like Allyson Tintiangco-Cubales, Jocyl Sacramento, and Barbara Jane Reyes to name a few, explain that Pinayism can be a "PLACE and space in the classroom where Pinay epistemologies, positionalities, and identities are at the center of the discourse"- encouraging Pinays to share dialogue allows us to better understand how we have come to know our unique experiences with culture, struggle, pains, and hopes. Such conversations as hard as they may be to come to terms with, and realizing how others' experiences of being Pinay might not be the same as our own, helps us to see beyond our similarities. Through voicing our differences, we feel and learn from one another what diversity entails- that all of our voices must be listened because life, our futures, should be as Pinayist Tintiangco-Cubales explains, one of"love and care for one another rather than [an existence where we] compete" for resources which is what fascists want us to to.
Taking together Dewey's desire for a free democratic society built on meaningful, knowledgeable, and diverse dialogue beginning in the classroom, coupled with Pinayist pedagogy that also values dialogue (envisioning the habit of communication as essential community praxis where we speak and listen to one another thoughtfully and with kindness in mind)- these two philosophies or experimental models of a democracy supporting education that center "communication to cultivate sympathy, intelligence, and creativity" is what will allow us to help what Tintiangco-Cubales describes as opportunities to "create meaningful relationships"and thus even more sustainable futures.
Reflective Teaching Has Reminded Me to Be Gentle With Myself and to Practice Tossing Out Worries and Things I Cannot Control. When the World Around Us Seems To Spiral, How Can I Make the Classroom a Space to Help Others Speak To One Another and Move Forward Together?
Reflecting on my time at the Wing Luke Museum after a conference, Seattle.
After all of this deliberate reflecting, reading, re-learning, and sitting in my discomfort and grief with everything that is happening around us both in the classroom and beyond it, I have new goals and hopes for the classroom. Moving forward I need to remind myself that I should focus on more organic opportunities for expressive dialogue in the classroom beyond the "academic discourse" or traditional "discussion" format we were trained in. Most importantly, like any new professor, I need to gently come to terms with the reality that I cannot affect everyone who enters the classroom. "Reflective teaching" has reminded me that the teacher-learner dynamic is also a type of relationship, meaning the pressure to pass knowledge on in a fruitful way also requires learners in the classroom to meet their teachers halfway. With all that aside, I can at least help the next generation of learners practice healthy listening and considerate dialogue which will inevitably, hopefully, lead to what Dewey and Tintiangco-Cubales described as learned habits that can allow them to cultivate sympathy for their peers and those around them.





Comments