The Queer Filipinx/a/o Read as a Mark of Marites

Greetings, the folks at the Peminist Team of Stacey’s Corner are back again to tsismis with you about Marites, our number one problematic favorite! This blog post marks the third installment of our multi-part series that taps into Marites’ hidden potential as a force for revolutionary and transformative good, that is, when she leverages her tsismis as a source of truth against neocolonial forces. Throughout the series we’ve explored the different forms that Marites has assumed: internet duwende (malicious troll) that proliferates false information online, local tsismosa/chismosa (gossip queen) that wreaks havoc on her neighborhood, and radical p/feminist co-conspirator that is a part of a community oriented intelligence network.
What remains consistent throughout these different variations of Marites is how she has been marked as an outsider by formal institutions of power (e.g. government, religion, and education) in Filipinx/a/o culture. Although, as an outsider, this provides Marites great insight and a unique perspective about how formal institutions of power operate. For example, drag queen superstar, Manila Luzon, reveals the connection between Philippine folklore and oppressive governmental regimes,
“Did you know that there are claims the aswang became a way to explain or even cover up the killings and the disappearances in the province because there are no news sources due to media censorship. Well, now you know. The killings and the disappearances done by the true villains are very real. The Aswangs! Well, look around you. Some of them run for office, not in drag” (Luzon, Drag Den, 00:44:30).
In typical Marites fashion, Luzon pokes critical fun at Philippine necolonial regimes by reframing these oppressive institutions as aswangs (shapeshifting bloodsucking monster); the “true villains'” who satiate their appetites and bloodlust by inflicting harm on Filipinx/a/o citizens. As Luzon perceptively notes, such normalized harm goes invisibilized, because these formal institutions place blame upon marginalized Filipinx/a/o communities and individuals to escape accountability, like Marites.
Marites is a convenient scape-goat for the “true villain” as someone who does not neatly conform to white supremacist and cis-heteropatriarchal beliefs that still underpins Filipinx/a/o culture. She is consequently misread as an outsider within her own Filipinx/a/o community and, yet, Marites proves to be an essential communal figure. Luzon reminds us that in the “province…there are no news sources due to media censorship,” word of mouth like tsimis becomes an essential method to decimate community knowledge. Mariteses, like Luzon, can consequently wield her tsismis as a form of community knowledge to decimate, deconstruct, and dismantle neocolonial institutions of power that threaten the wellbeing and safety of her community. Unfortunately, these corrupt forces have hijacked Marites and her potential to be a voice for her community.
The presidential rise of Bong-Bong Marcos has allowed us to witness how formal institutions of power have manipulated the image of Marites to perpetuate neocolonial violence and control. For instance, online Mariteses have been responsible for “media censorship” by propagating false tsismis, particularly against Filipina journalists like Marites Vitug who has been outspoken about the Marcos family’s human rights atrocities (PressOne, “FACT-CHECK,” 1). The mis-use of online Mariteses have therefore reaffirmed cis-heteronormative and patriarchal values that ironically regulate her as an outsider. This blog series still believes firmly that Marites can still be a p/feminist co-conspirator even as she risked being enveloped by the same formal institutions of power that attempts to oppress her. Therefore, using a queer of color critique and queer Filipinx/a/o figures, the peminists at Stacey’s Corner believe that Marites and her tsismis can still retain her subversive nature when she leaves the province for the mainstream center stage, whether that is online, on the news, or even in our own community networks.
Marites, Your Colonial Roots are Showing!?

Formal institutions of power, as remnants of western colonialism and imperialism, reaffirm their presence in Filipinx/a/o culture by regulating nonnormative figures like Marites to the margins of society. Indeed, Marites is a subversive figure under Filipinx/a/o culture that still encourages white supremacist and cis-heteropatriarchal gender constructs. Even though she may weaponize her tsismis to uphold such beliefs and practices within her own community.
White supremacist and cis-heteropatriarchal gender constructs that regulate Marites to the margins of Filipinx/a/o culture is a legacy of western colonialism. According to feminist scholars like Maria Lugones, contemporary “gender-systems” are created by gender, race, and colonization (Lugones, “Coloniality of Gender,” 1). As a Comparative Literature scholar, Lugones explores the nexuses of gender, race, and colonization through Third World and Women of Color Feminist literature.
Many different feminists of color have contributed to the body of work that speaks to and seeks to dismantle the intersectional and violent nature of settler colonialism; each grappling with the legacies of western colonialism within their respective communities. In particular, Lugones cites Oyèrónkẹ́ Oyěwùmí, a Nigerian gender scholar and sociologist, for their “[understanding] that gender as introduced by the West as a tool of domination that designates two binarily opposed and hierarchical social categories,” which was non-existent in Nigeria prior to western colonialism (Lugones, “Coloniality of Gender,” 7). Western colonialism, in other words, forcibly introduced white supremacy through cis-heteronormative, homophobic, and patriarchal gender constructs to Indigenous and Native communities.
The Spanish, through military violence and Catholic ideology, likewise created “opposed and hierarchical social categories,” which especially exploits Filipinas and queer Filipinx/a/o people. In order to understand such “violent domination and exploitation,” Lugones emphasizes the need to see race, gender, class, and sexuality as inseparable and interlocking (Lugones, “Coloniality of Gender'', 1). The need to understand how categories of difference overlap is also the inspiration behind Roderick Ferguson’s work and coining of the “queer of color critique” (QOC). QOC is a theoretical framework that positions queer people of color at the center of critical analysis. As people who exist within the intersections of multiple marginalized identities, queer people of color occupy a unique vantage point where they witness how race, gender, class, and sexuality are all simultaneously at play.
Ferguson, a scholar of African American and Gender and Women's Studies, contextualizes queer of color critique within the Black community. However, the theoretical framework can still be applied to the Filipinx/a/o community, because of similar struggles in our community to understand how categories of difference overlap, as seen through the tragic death of Jennifer Laude in 2014. Laude was a 26 year old transgender Filipina who was murdered in Olongapo City by a visiting American marine, Joseph Scott Pemberton, while engaging in sex work.
Philipinne media outlets were particularly notorious for weaponizing homophobic and transphobic language to describe Laude as “a man like [Pemberton],” causing Pemberton to “feel like he was being raped,” (Raval, Call Her Ganda, 01:37:17). The coverage of Laude’s death provides a vivid example of how neocolonial violence towards Filipinx/a women is reaffirmed due to the “categorial separation of race, gender, class, and sexuality” (Lugone, “Coloniality of Gender'', 1). Ultimately, media outlets justified Laude’s death by (mis)categorizing Jennifer under one identity.
Marites, “You're Perfect, You're a Model, You Look like a Gender Anarchist, did you Stone that Dress?”
Similar to Laude, Marites defies easy binaries and neat categorization. Neocolonial powers consequently conflate Marites under one identity: kontrabida, or a “failed women who is asking for racialized-gendered violence”. It is her perceived preoccupation with tsismis which compels her to leave home and neglect her womanly responsibilities. By “failing” to provide gendered labor associated with traditional Filipina femininity, Marites transgresses white supremacist, cis-heteronormative, and patriarchal beliefs instilled within Filipix/a/o culture about what constitutes a respectable Filipina.
Marites’ inability to conform to fixed gender constructs frames her as a “bad” or “defective” Filipina, but her perceived weakness can also be her strengths. We can reframe her societal failings as a site for critical self-reflection about the racialized-gendered hierarchies that we’ve somehow assumed were implicitly true in Filipinx/a/o culture. Alongside her we can ask how white supremacist, cis-heteronormative, and patriarchal structures exploit all of us, and who these structures actually benefit.
Marites who clumsily finds herself in everyone’s business surprisingly becomes a potential gender anarchist! But, she first has to deconstruct how racialized-gendered hierarchies retain their control by making it difficult to trace the intersections of sexuality, race, gender, and class. Perhaps it is no wonder that the most effective and notable formation of the Marites tends to be queer Filipinx/a/o folks! Similar to Filipinas, queer Filipinx/a/o people exist within the intersections of race, gender, class, and sexuality. Existing within these categories of differences forces queer Filipinx/a/o people to learn the intricacies of these racialized-gendered hierarchies to endure their circumstance and preserve their personhood. In the process, many queer Filipinx/a/o people and communities become experts about their own outsider status. This expertise knowledge can therefore be subverted against the same systems of harm from which it emerges from, and into a source of comedic material to derive community joy and solidarity.
Marites, The Library is Open!

Other queer communities of color have likewise created their own community practices and traditions that speak to this need to create laughter from tears and grief, like reading! As RuPaul would say, “Reading is Fundamental!” Reading has its history in the New York City Black and Latine/Latinx drag-ballroom scene which sets the stage for much of Paris is Burning. The influential 1991 documentary provides an iconic definition of reading from Dorian Corey, esteemed drag queen and drag mother:
“Reading is the real art form of insults. You get in a smart crack, and everyone laughs and kikis, because you found a flaw and exaggerated it, and you’ve got a good read going. If it’s happening between the gay world and the straight world, it’s not really a read. It’s more of an insult, a vicious slur fight. But it’s how they develop a sense of how to read,” (Corey, Paris is Burning, 00:33:15).
At its core, reading is a radical community-based practice that arises when two queer people on equal footing can playfully banter about their marginal status under white supremacist, cis-heteronormative, and patriarchal structures that threaten their existence.
A “good” read returns the gaze of these racialized-gendered hierarchies against itself while delightfully laughing in its face. According to Oliver Wood when examining the reading challenges in RuPaul’s Drag Race, some of the pleasures that undergirds reading is how it “ foregrounds a more sustained critique of heteronormative hierarchies of (in)civility and (in)justice that are indexed to one’s sexuality, race, gender, class, and more” (Wood, “Reading is Fun-Da-Mental,” 2521). Even though the reader can “[appropriate] the cruelty directed at them by patriarchal society,” reading does contain the “politically progressive” potential to subvert and dismantle these racialized-gendered hierarchies by critically examining how categories of difference operate to disenfranchise all of us (Wood, “Reading is Fun-Da-Mental,” 2521). By critically poking fun at the racist and cis-hetero norms in society that intentionally goes invisibilized, reading can be seen as a radical form of resistance.
Marites, You Better Tsimis!
Tsismis can also be a radical form of resistance. Figures like Manila Luzon prove that tsismis can go against structures of oppression by critically poking fun at how these structures work. Tsismis and the read therefore contains “politically progressive” potential by making visible a “flaw” in these racialized-gendered hierarchies, and “exaggerating” it to comedic effect. However, tsismis diverges from reading in the sense that it is a culturally intuitive practice unique to the Filipinx/a/o community. P/feminist scholar, Allyson Tintiangco-Cubales, describes how pinayism as a theoretical framework draws upon feminism and woman of color feminism, but was specifically created to capture the unique Filipina lived experience as people who were shaped by “race/ethnicity, class, gender, sexuality, spirituality/religion, educational status, age, place of birth, Diasporic migration,” (Cubales, "Pinayism", 141). Tsimis also borrows from reading, but is meant to reflect the culturally specific ways in which the Filipinx/a/o community distinctly experiences and resists against neocolonialism, white-supremacy, and cis-heteropatriarchy.
Other similarities that tsismis and the read share is that they both elicit strong feelings of distrust and disgust. Tsismis specifically garners criticism within the Filipinx/a/o community as a practice which reaffirms cis-heteronormativity and patriarchy, as seen through online Mariteses who support Bong-Bong Marcos’ presidency. This new wave of Mariteses undermines tsismis’ pre-colonial origins (PEP.ph,“Ano raw?”). According to social anthropologist, Nestor T. Castro, Marites can trace back her ancestral roots to the umalohokan, “or the town crier during pre-Hispanic Philippines” (PEP.ph,“Ano raw?). When Spain colonized the Philippines and its Indigenous peoples, one method of control was suppressing community knowledge and its systems of community-knowledge-production which included the umalohokan: “The [Spanish] government decided that news only comes from Spanish authorities and loyal subjects. Everything else was considered tsismis (PEP.ph,“Ano raw?”). Tsismis therefore has its roots as subversive community knowledge that threatened western colonial powers.
Western colonialism therefore weaponized sexist, patriarchal, and cis-heternormative logics to regulate tsimsis as mere “gossip” or misinformation, and undermine the practice’s capability to unravel colonial social constructions like “sexuality, race, gender, class, and more” (Wood, “Reading is Fun-Da-Mental,” 2521). These racialized-gendered dynamics are noticeably missing within the current discourse about Marites. For instance, Jefferson M. Cuadram argues that the emergent online Marites culture highlights the “increasing importance of online communication and the influence of traditional gossip practices.” (Cuadram, “Marites Culture in the Philippines,“ 1) Cuadros’ article provides wonderful insight about Marites as a recent cultural phenomenon. The article also promotes gendered universals by presenting tsismis as “a natural inclination,” by “a specific population that excels in this activity” to gain social capital (Cuadram, “Marites Culture in the Philippines,“ 5). Unfortunately, such statements do not take into account the colonial history that underpins the construction of Marites and her tsismis, and promotes neocolonialism by invisibilizing sexuality, race, gender, and class from the conversation.
Mari-YASSSSSSSSSS

Through tsismis, Marites can return the gaze of these racialized-gendered hierarchies against itself to advocate for her community against neocolonial systems of domination and exploitation. Marites has indeed kept this rebellious flare despite her and her tsismis entering mainstream institutions. In particular, queer Filipinx/a/o people in the diaspora and the homeland have taken the mantle of Marites as they strut across the center stage, diba (right)?
One of the best examples of a queer p/feminist co-conspirator who refashions tsismis to help her community is Manila Luzon. Luzon is widely considered to be one of the most memorable contestants to grace the stage of RuPaul’s Drag Race (RPDR), and since RPDR she has propelled herself to drag global superstardom as host, head judge, and executive producer of Drag Den Philippines which premiered on Amazon Prime this 2022. A drag competition that regularly provides political commentary against neo colonial powers affecting the queer Filipinx/a/o community and the broader Philippines.
The main challenge from one notable episode in the series, titled “Drag is Political,” is Drag Den’s Women of Power which challenges contestants to convey how the “struggles of women, and the struggles of the LGBTQ community are intersectional” using their drag (00:24:00). Contestants like Barbie-Q, who is also a trans woman, appears with the following lines:
“Trans women are women. We deserve to be loved. We don’t deserve to be treated like sex toys who are at your service everytime you need us. You only love us when you need us. We also deserve to use the same toilets as other women because we are women. Trans women are women…We just really want to pee. Thank you” (Barbie-Q, “Drag is Political”, 00:22:01).
Barbie-Que’s drag performance reveals the common ground in which the read and tsismis meet.
By using her outsider positionality as a trans woman, Barbie-Que is critically poking fun at the racialized-gendered hierarchies that prevent trans women from being seen as a legible woman, and the consequent violence that this entails. For example, her drag performance is a read in the sense that she identifies and mocks the absurd hypocrisy in Filipinx/a/o culture to invisibilize trans women. By mentioning and poking fun that trans people “just want to pee,” she is critically calling attention to contemporary issues and homophobic policies that queer Filipinx/a/o communities have witnessed.
According to Llanesca T. Panti of GMA News, in 2019, 47% of pinoys considered it “too radical” for trans women to use the female comfort room (CR, restroom). As noted in Panti’s piece, the Philippine public’s opinion leans towards the desire to uphold cis-heteronromativity in all facets of society. Such strong opinions consequently brings about the legal and physical erasure of queer Filipinx/a/o people and communities. “In Defense of the X,” scholars like Kay et al. argue that cis-hetero norms have infiltrated and upheld Philippine legal infrastructures, therefore erasing the possibility for trans and queer Filipinx/a/o people to peacefully exist in either public or private spaces (2021, Alon,133).
The invisibilization of trans and queer Filipinx/a/o people in Philippines’ legal infrastructure, “can lead to violence in private, public, and institutional spheres” (Kay et al., “In Defense of the X,”133). Kay et al. cites the 2019 arrest of Gretchen Custodia Diez in Cubao to support their argument. Diez is a Filipinx/a trans woman who was waiting in line for the woman’s CR when a janitress suddenly singled her out to force her into the men’s bathroom. When Diez asked the janitress to provide an explanation behind her actions on camera, “this enraged the janitress, who ‘dragged’ her to the security room to have her arrested” (Talabong, “Trans woman Gretchen Diez"). Consequently, the police attempted to criminally prosecute Diez even though they “could not immediately decide what case to file against her,” (Talabong, “Trans woman Gretchen Diez"). The janitress and the police were not able to explain the logic behind Diez’s arrest, revealing that there were no legal grounds for her arrest, detainment, and criminalization. Yet, there was an unspoken agreement between the respective parties that Diez was already a criminal, and that legal structures would be the appropriate route to punish her.
We can refer back to Barbie-Q’s drag performance to provide insight about the structural and interpersonal violence that regularly endangers trans women like Diez. Barbie-Q’s wish to“use the same toilets as other women because…trans women are women,” is also tsimis in the sense that she reveals queer community knowledge about how violence against trans women in public spaces is unfortunately common. Homophobic and gendered violence occurs within Filipinx/a/o culture because public opinion misreads trans women as men.
The media coverage of Jennifer Laude’s death by Joseph Scott Pemberley reaffirms Barbie-Q’s tsismis that trans women in Filipinx/a/o culture are not perceived as women. Rather, trans Filipinas are read and legally defined as men who, according to broader Filipina/o public opinion, intentionally disguise themselves as women to deceive cis-heterosexual men to gain profit (Raval, Call Her Ganda, 01:37:17). Thus, transgender women, from a Filipino hetero-patriarchal dominant culture perspective, are perceived as manipulative liars that are deserving of structural and interpersonal violence for threatening cis-heterornomative and inflexible gender binaries for “their own benefit.”
Manila Luzon’s tsismis (introduced in the beginning of the post) critiques Philippines’ legal infrastructure that inflicts structural and interpersonal violence against queer Filipinx/a/o people:
“Did you know that there are claims the aswang became a way to explain or even cover up the killings and the disappearances in the province because there are no news sources due to media censorship. Well, now you know. The killings and the disappearances done by the true villains are very real. The Aswangs! Well, look around you. Some of them run for office, not in drag.” (Luzon, Drag Den, 00:44:30)
She critically pokes fun at a dual reality that queer Filipinx/a/o people and communities are forced to traverse. That drag queens, trans gender women, and other queer Filipinx/a/o communities are perceived as aswangs. In reality, it is those that wield their power dangerously within the government that are the real aswangs and “true villains.”
As the death of Jennifer Laude and the wrongful arrest of Gretchen Diez reveals, cis-heteronormative and patriarchal gender constructs underpins Philippines’ legal infrastructure which leads to neo colonial violence. Queer Filipinx/a/o communities are especially susceptible to such violence because their existence threatens these taken for granted gender constructs. Using tsismis, Luzon returns the gaze of these racialized-gendered hierarchies against itself; exposing how queer Filipinx/a/o communities are much more likely to be the victims of killings, disappearances, and media censorship at the hands of the real aswangs who uphold cis-heternormative and patriarchal gender constructs. Mariteses, like Luzon and Barbie-Q, wield their tsismis for good to expose these dual realities; and, therefore, the intersections where comedy, gender, and neocolonial violence converge to advocate for the safety and wellbeing of their communities.
Conclusion
As seen through queer p/feminist figures like Manila Luzon and Barbie-Q, Marites is considered a societal outcast and failure for her inability to conform to white supremacist, cis-heteronormative, and patriarchal structures that still flourishes within Filipinx/a/o culture. She can indeed perpetuate colonial mentality. However, more often than not, we are laughing at her rather than with her. Instead of regulating Marites to the butt of our jokes and the outskirts of our community, this series encourages us to reflect on the subversive potential of Marites when she critically pokes fun at the painfully obvious ills in our community. If so, we can then embrace her as one of our own, and reframe Marites’ read and tsismis as her way of simply asking us to want more for ourselves and the larger Filipinx/a/o-community. This brings us back to our original question: Is it possible for Marites and her tsismis to retain her subversive nature when she is enveloped within the same formal institutions that have created her marginalized status? The answer is yasssssssss, queen!

Ingat fellow readers and peminist wanderers.





Comments