FAHM Film Review: A Filipinx Critical Gay(ze) About Queer and Undocumented Lived Realities

Introduction: Continuing Conversations about the United States’ Role in the Phillipine Diaspora
Greetings again everyone! The Peminist Team of Stacey’s Corner wishes you the very best as this is the last week of Fil-Am History Month. We hope this FAHM has provided many opportunities to be in community with other Fil-Am folks; to celebrate Fil-Am history, and to reflect on how these shared legacies of US colonialism still reverberate to this day. We understand that the latter may be challenging, so we want to keep assisting y’all in your individual and collective journeys in learning more about Fil-Am history and lived experiences through two more Philippine and Fil-Am films: Undocumented by Jose Antonio Vargas and Lingua Franca by Isabel Sandoval.
Undocumented (2013) and Lingua Franca (2019) share many similarities with the last films discussed in our previous blog post. All of these films center the lived realities of LGBTQIA+ Filipinx folks who struggle to self-name themselves under the sexual, gendered, and racial legacies caused by western imperialism and colonialism. However, what sets Undocumented and Lingua Franca apart from the last films is that these stories take place in the United States, and the main characters grapple with an additional layer of marginalization surrounding their undocumented status.
The Peminist Team of Stacey’s Corner strongly believe in approaching Fil-Am identity and history through the lens of intersectionality, or how Filipinx/a/o folks have multiple and compounding marginalized identities that work together to create distinct experiences of disenfranchisement. Rather than approaching queer identities and undocumented status as separate, we’ll be examining how both these social categories mutually build upon each other and shape the lived experiences of undocumented Filipinx/a/o folks. By examining the relationship between queerness and undocumented status, this blog post reflects on the multitude of ways that Filipinx/a/o people across the Fil-Am diaspora are forced to “pass” as legible US citizens, largely to protect themselves from systemic violence at the hands of the state.
Documented (2013)
A Conversation on how Colonial Powers Benefit in Separating Families through Structural and Institutionalized Violence

Documented (2013) is an autobiographical documentary directed by Jose Antonio Vargas. Vargas is a Pulitzer-Prize winning journalist who published an essay for the New York Times in 2011 that disclosed his undocumented status to the entire country. Similar to the lived realities of other undocumented folks, Vargas had been hiding his undocumented status for most of his life, out of fear that he would be the target of institutional violence—primarily deportation. Deportation would not only entail obvious consequences for Vargas, but also his mother and siblings back in the Philippines who depended on his remittances for their livelihood. Vargas’ trajectory to the United States was largely driven by the poor socioeconomic conditions in the Philippines that can be traced back to the ongoing labor drain enacted by US colonial and postcolonial policies. Such labor migration networks and policies for over a century have exploited the Philippines and have led to incessant and violent extractions of both natural resources and human labor. With very limited pathways to generate income, undocumented folks like Vargas find themselves in the United States, compelled to hide their identities and often leading many to suffer in virtual isolation and silence.
But, as the documentary emphasized, Vargas was in a very unique position compared to other undocumented folks. He was a well-connected and critically acclaimed journalist. Therefore, he had the social and economic capital that provided him a platform to publicly disclose his undocumented status and allowed him to legally represent himself in Congress. Vargas used these “advantages” to “elevate the immigration conversation,” or humanize the narrative around undocumented people who are easy targets of systemic violence in the United States, because they cannot accurately represent themselves and their lived experiences without outing their undocumented status.
Besides having to hide being undocumented, for a long time Vargas also had to hide the fact that he was a gay from his family:
“I also knew that I was gay and I couldn't be in the closet about two things at once, and I had to get out of one of them. And this was easier…Coming out to Lolo (grandfather) and to Lola (grandmother) was almost like -- was almost like asserting myself and saying that this is who I am. I had no control over that part, but I have control over this part.” (Vargas, ).
Many LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o folks inherit internalized shame for not being cisgender and/or heterosexual, and consequently hide their queer identities from their families. This likely stems from western colonial ideology that attempted to create racialized subjects through extremely narrow cis-heterosexual social categories. The United States continues to create ideal racial, sexual, and gendered citizens through its legislative policies. For example, the documentary was filmed before gay marriage was legalized in 2015, so hypothetically Vargas could have accessed a pathway to citizenship through marrying a woman. A future that Vargas’ lolo (grandfather) had hoped for. Vargas would have been “rewarded” by the United States with citizenship if he had conformed to the country's cis-heternormative and patriarchal values rooted in white supremacy. By connecting his gay identity and undocumented status together, Vargas presented both as transgressive politicized identities that are marked by a sense of un-belonging in a racist cis-heteronormative nation state and in a traditional Fil-Am household that tried to survive through assimilation.
The heart of Vargas’ narrative is his broken relationship with his mother who he hasn’t seen in person since he left the Philippines. Vargas admits that he intentionally hid his mother’s existence, because he feared that their relationship would reveal his undocumented status. His double life highlights how undocumented LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o folks are highly susceptible to ongoing western colonial exploitation and erasure; in large part because they have to hide the systemic violence they experience as undocumented and queer people out of fear that the violence may escalate and/or affect their loved ones.
Lingua Franca (2019)
Transgender Filipina Resistance Against Larger Structures of Colonial Violence in the Philippines and the United States

Conversations about poverty, undocumented status, and queer erasure presented in Undocumented continues in Lingua Franca (2019). Directed by Isabel Sandoval, Lingua Franca takes place in 2019, and is about Olivia, a fictional transgender Filipina who struggles with her undocumented status. Like Vargas, Olivia left her family back in the Philippines, and they still depend on her and her monthly income that she earned working as a caretaker for an elderly woman in Brooklyn. In both these films the threat of poverty can be seen as a form of systemic violence perpetrated by western colonial states, because the West actively benefits from the separation of families through creating a steady flow of undocumented folks that are exploited as a cheap labor force. But, unlike Vargas, Olivia's work is considered “unskilled” labor. It does not provide her the social and economic capital that would open pathways for her to legally represent herself, or protection against systemic violence if her undocumented status were to be revealed. The film explores how Olivia, as an undocumented transgender Filipina, renegotiated and resisted the structural constraints imposed on her as a person who exists within the complicated intersections of racism, sexism, transphobia, and undocumented status. Under these growing pressures, and the Trump administration's mass ICE (US Immigration and Customs Enforcement) deportation campaign, Olivia also begins a romantic relationship with the grandson of the elderly woman who she cares for.
Olivia is forced to hide her transgender identity and undocumented status from those around her. The only person in the film who truly knows Olivia is her childhood best friend from the Philippines, Trixie, who is also a transgender woman. Olivia and Trixie are subjected to structural and institutional violence by the Philippine government which has material consequences for them in the United States. Their relationship is therefore important, because it offers a rare example of female solidarity between two undocumented transgender women, and how their emotional bond provides a momentary refuge against countries that operate under western cis-heteropatriarchy and a fixed gender binary. In the film, one of these moments is when Olivia confides in Trixie about her frustration about how the Philippine government recently passed a bill that prevented transgender people from legally changing their names and gender on their passports.
“But this isn’t me anymore. Neither my name or gender. To think I wouldn’t have to alter these if they didn’t go out of their way to pass that damn bill back home.” (Olivia, 00:19:59)
According to scholars like Kay Ulanday Barrett, Karen Buenavista Hanna, and Anang Palomar, without “legal precedent” that respects transgender, gender-nonconforming, and non-binary Filipinx/a/o folks right to self-name and identify themselves, such bills gives rise to normalized “violence in private, public, and institutional spheres” (Barrett, Hanna, et al., “In Defense of the X”, 132-133). For transgender undocumented folks like Olivia, not having the accurate information on their passport could lead to forms of institutionalized racism and state-sanctioned violence like immigration raids and deportation. Olivia’s precarious position is unfortunately dependent on whether she can “pass'' as a documented and cisgendered person, under the racist cis-heterpatriarchal gaze of the United States.
Lingua Franca ends with Olivia rejecting a marriage proposal from Alex (the grandson of the elderly woman she was the caretaker for), despite knowing that marriage could open a pathway for her to obtain a green card. Olivia may have refused Alex’s offer, because she learned that he lied and kept her passport away from her. From Olivia’s point of view, Alex might have enacted interpersonal violence against Olivia; and, since learning the truth, now represented a larger social, economic, and legal system that utilizes everyday patriarchal violence upon undocumented transgender Filipinx folks through stealing, taking ownership, and rewriting their existence. By rejecting him, she follows in the footsteps of other undocumented LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o folks—like Vargas— who asserted their agency under the constraints of such a system and also knew the material consequences that resisting could entail.
Concluding on a Reflection about Undocumentedness, Queerness, and FAHM
Both films express how undocumented LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o folks are at particular risk(s) of racist, homophobic, and transphobic structural and institutional violence. Undocumented and Lingua Franca are likewise in historical conversation with one another. Undocumented was released in 2011-2012, a time where the social, political, and legislative landscape seemed to be somewhat more receptive to hearing the lived realities of undocumented folks. Fast forward to Lingua Franca being released in 2019, the political landscape spoke to conservative and xenophobic rhetoric under the Trump administration. During these historical shifts, the US continued to perpetuate such debilitating socioeconomic conditions on immigrant and undocumented communities. Such conditions forced Filipinx/a/o folks to leave their homeland and their families in pursuit of work. Once they arrive in the United States, Filipinx/a/o are viewed and used as an exploitable racialized workforce. Such a never ending cycle of labor extraction and migration highlights how the United States on both ends of the Pacific actively benefits from its imperial relationship with the Philippines, putting Filipinx/a/o wellbeing, safety, and self-determination at risk.
We explored these films through a Filipinx critical lens to examine how diverse LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o folks in the homeland and the diaspora continue to resist colonial, white supremecist, and cis-heteropatriarchal forces through everyday acts of resistance and mass mobilization. By exploring LGBTQIA+ Filipinx/a/o folks’ compounding marginalized identities, the fraught interlocking relationships between race, gender, sexuality, citizenship, undocumented status, and colonialism, the Peminist Team at Stacey’s Corner hope that these topics resonate with all of you. Let’s continue to engage in new lines of thinking about and celebrating Filipinx/a/o histories and lived realities even after FAHM is over.
Ingat fellow readers and peminist wanderers.





Comments