A Holiday Review of Philippine Teleseryes: Tackling Misogyny in Replacing Chef Chico

Greetings! As usual, the Peminist Team of Stacey’s Corner hopes that this blog post finds you and everyone around you in good spirits, especially during this holiday season. For those of us in the Filipinx/a/o community who celebrate Pasko (Christmas), we know that this time of the year is eh-special, because it entails many joyful festivities with our loved ones.
We are therefore dedicating a spotlight towards our favorite pastime at the center of these Pasko celebrations: cooking Filipino food!
Indeed, the Filipinx/a/o community has a soft spot (both in our bellies and our hearts) for food, because of its ability to bring us all back to the table with our loved ones. Dawn Mabalon, scholar activist and community historian who specialized in Filipinx/a/o-American history in Stockton, described cuisine as “a powerful symbol of [Filipinx/a/o-American] collective struggle to survive despite overwhelming odds” (Mabalon, “As American as Jackrabbit Adobo,” 2013, 148). Mabalon’s statement can resonate with many of us who have prepared and/or shared meals with older family members, and witnessed how conversations naturally arise about which dishes (or lack thereof) are connected to familial histories and struggles spanning across the homeland and the diaspora. Food therefore operates as a mirror in which Filipinx/a/o people, families, and communities can see themselves reflected within. That is why this blog-post will be a love letter dedicated to the significance of food in the Filipinx/a/o community!
We’ll be examining how cooking food is a practice that ties the individual to the broader Filipinx/a/o community together. Using the series Replacing Chef Chico (2023) as a point of pop culture reference, the peminists at Stacey’s Corner will dive into the Filipinx/a/o holiday spirit by highlighting some of the ways Philippine food reckon with family tsismis, brings us closer to talking story, and overall bringing us together as kapwa (finding our cultural selves in others; to be with community).
Replacing Chef Chico (Spoiler Alert!)
Replacing Chef Chico is a Filipinx/a/o eight part series that aired on Netflix this past November. The series takes place at Hain, a fine dining restaurant based in the homeland that specializes in Filipinx/a/o cuisine, and closely follows Ellen (artista, Alessandra De Rossi). When we first meet Ellen she is introduced as Hain’s sous chef, and we get a clear understanding that she doesn't believe in her own culinary capabilities even though she has recognizable talent, passion, and work ethic. Instead, she regulates herself as the right hand woman to Chico (Sam Milby), Hain’s head chef who treats her as his lesser half both professionally and romantically. Until, Ellen finds herself competing for the head chef position when Chico ends up in a coma due to a car accident (don’t drive and text, guys). From there, the series closely follows Ellen as she struggles to overcome her lack of self-confidence and the misogynistic culinary culture found in the kitchen, and beyond, to become a well renowned head chef across Asia. Ellen fortunately has allies in the kitchen including Raymond (Piolo Pascual), a consultant hired by Hain’s upper management to help save the restaurant from the chopping block.
It’s a Man’s Kitchen

You think you’re tired of reading about misogyny, sexism, and patriarchy for these past three months at Stacey’s Corner? How do you think the folxs at the Peminist Team feel…How do you think we feel! (ಥ‿ಥ) Joke lang! It’s impossible to avoid these systems of oppression when they underpin every facet of Filipinx/a/o social infrastructure, including the restaurant industry! Filipinas like Ellen are consequently forced to endure, maneuver, and resist against these sexist beliefs and practices in her everyday life.
“Episode 2” of Replacing Chef Chico reveals how sexist and patriarchal beliefs are ingrained into the culinary world thus feeding and reinforcing broader patriarchal Filipinx/a/o values. After Chico enters his coma, Raymond contacts Hain’s upper management (who also happens to be Chico’s mother) to inform her about the severity of his condition. Upper management, referred to as VLG, immediately jumps to the conclusion that Chico’s sous chef or replacement is a man, “Whoever who he is, you make sure he doesn’t f*ck up Chico’s reputation…The sous chef is a woman?...Are you sure? Can she handle the restaurant, Raymond?” (VLG, “Episode 2”, 00:01:17). Her statement reveals that within the Filipinx/a/o culinary world, Filipinas are seen as inadequate candidates to assume leadership positions in the kitchen. Furthermore, when the kitchen staff also learns about Chico’s coma, they refuse to acknowledge Ellen as their new head chef, illustrating that they share VLG’s sexist doubts about Filipinas in positions of authority. Such sentiments reflect the real life gendered barriers that prevent Filipinas from becoming leaders in the restaurant industry.
Alison N.C. Reiheld, a scholar of philosophy specializing in ethics and value theory, reveals that “Chefs and heads of staff in commercial kitchens remain overwhelmingly men,” and when men do cook, “it is mainly public cooking, the food of money and prestige” (Reiheld, “Gender Norms and Food Behaviors,” 1098). Reiheld argues that the entire enterprise of food (i.e. production, preparation, and consumption) across the public and private sphere are deeply informed by sexist gender norms that limit women’s agency.
Women are almost always confined to private spheres. For example, “anglo-heritage nations'' presents home cooking as a womanly practice inextricably tied to “feminine virtue and a duty to a family” (Reiheld,“Gender Norms and Food Behaviors,” 1096-1098). Western traditions consider home cooking as a form of expected unpaid domestic female labor. Reiheld argues that these traditional western gender constructs inform societal understanding that women’s labor is inherently cheap or free, and therefore has “no market value” in public spheres like restaurants (Reiheld, “Gender Norms and Food Behaviors,” 1098).
Reiheld’s findings reveal that western gender constructs which “regulate[s] women’s food preparation predominantly to the private sector,” causes women to be seen as a cheap and gendered labor force in the restaurant industry (“Gender Norms and Food Behaviors,” 1098). Even though they contribute greatly to the industry the labor of women chefs are consequently taken for granted and devalued.
Gender constructs which present women as naturally belonging to the private sphere of cooking also creates sexist stereotypes. Specifically, that women chefs are motherly or sisterly figures in the kitchen. Women are then regulated to supporting roles that are meant to benefit men. This corresponds with authors like Bonnie Tsui in “Queens of the Kitchen,” who highlights how women chefs are pigeonholed as “warm and nurturing,” in comparison to men chefs who are allowed to be “mavericks; [who] break rules, experiment, innovate,” (Tsui, “Queens of the Kitchen, 2). However, Tsui centers women of color chefs in her narrative to reveal how sexism, patriarchy, and racism are simultaneously at play.
Girl, Pick Yourself Up (From These Racialized-Gendered Hierarchies)
Women of color are particularly affected by western gender constructs as people who are both gendered and racialized. These intersectional identities therefore entail considerable barriers designed to regulate women of color chefs as “motherly” figures instead of innovators and game-changers in the industry.
“It is likely that there are so few female chefs of color [in the United
States]...because women of color that would be chefs don’t see themselves
reflected in the country’s kitchen. Opening a restaurant may not seen like a
viable option when the vast majority of restaurants are white men.”
(Tsui, “Queens of the Kitchen,” 3)
Such a statement points to how racialized-gendered hierarchies rooted in the West have infiltrated the culinary culture, specifically, by creating systemic issues that allow white men to be seen as the “face” of the industry (Tsui, “Queens of the Kitchen, 2).
As people who exist at the bottom of these racialized-gendered herchies, women of color chefs are not considered leaders within the culinary field which hinders them from achieving their professional goals. Tsui’s observations bring to mind episode one of Replacing Chef Chico. Ellen at the very beginning of the episode is asked by Nanay (mother) Dita, the motherly figure of the kitchen staff, why Ellen hasn’t pursued her own dreams of opening a restaurant. Ellen implies that she prefers to stay in Hain to prioritize Chico’s dreams instead of her own. As Ella says to Chico amidst one of his breakdowns:
“Three years of being your second in command. I’ve demonstrated my
loyalty to you. You know I support you in the choices you make. So
whatever that burden is, please put some of it on me.” (“Episode 1”,
00:05:57)
Ellen’s sentiments are sweet. However, a critical examination reveals how she doesn’t consider herself to be deserving of a spot at the forefront of the culinary world. She naturally supports Chico instead so he can occupy that position for himself in the future. Racialized-gendered hierarchies within culinary culture, and the broader Filipinx/a/o society, therefore prioritizes the desires and needs of men over women. Ellen also reveals how Filipinx/a/o culture has deeply internalized these racialized-gendered hierarchies to such an extent that they’ve become gut instinct.
This is a Recipe for Disaster.

Filipinx/a/o-American historians like René Alexander D. Orquiza uses food production to trace how racialized-gendered hierarchies in the Philippines emerged. For example, Orquiza states how American influences like “cookbooks by Americans in the Philippines announced their missionary zeal and clear preference for Western cuisines in their promise of food’s power to bring a better life for the average Filipino,” (Orquiza, “Taste of Control,” 89). Orquiz, in other words, argues that cookbooks and cuisine were weaponized by Americans to enact their policies of “benevolent assimilation,” over the Philippines.
Cookbooks written by American expats, like Good Cooking and Health in the Tropics (1922) by Elsie McCloskey Gaches, openly voiced their beliefs about the racial inferiority of Filipinx/a/o cuisine which was a larger attack against Filipinx/a/o culture, history, people, and way of life (Orquiza, “Taste of Control,” 90). American cuisine through the eyes of Gaches would consequently become a suitable method to racially “uplift” and civilize the Philippines. Orquiz however highlights that “benevolent assimilation” justified America’s ongoing military presence in the Pacific and the economic exploitation of Philippine’s natural resources (Orquiza, “Taste of Control,” 40). Cookbooks therefore helped legitimize America’s colonial projects of empire building by establishing racialized hierarchies between American and Filipinx/a/o cuisine.
These racialized hierarchies were also underpinned by patriarchal and sexist logics. Orquiza explains that Good Cooking was published under the American Guardian Association; an organization that helped assist 18,000 Filipinx/a/o orphans who were dispossessed in the dual Philippine wars against Spain and America (Orquiza, “Taste of Control,” 89). The introduction of Good Cooking mentions these orphans, particularly Filipina girls, “The girls will be educated for business, nursing, teaching, etc., if they show aptitude, and will be so trained that they will develop into good, capable wives of honest men,” (Orquiza, “Taste of Control,” 90). Statements such as these provide insight into how American influence reaffirmed racialized-gendered hierarchies which regulated Filipinas as desirable wives for their future husbands.
By presenting Filipinas as mere extensions of their husbands, this would contribute to a culture of machismo (male chauvinism)which normalizes the gendered dominance of Filipinos over Filipinas. For example, for those who grew up in a Filipinx/a/o household, Chico’s random saputon (Cebuana for ill-tempered) mood swings and explosive anger might feel like familiar behavior exhibited by Filipino men; behavior that Filipino men regularly exhibit to instill cis-heteropatriachal fear and control within the household. However, it is Filipinas like Ellen who are responsible for performing the gendered and affective labor of calming Filipino men down from their incoherent response to dealing and internalizing emotional situations. Unfortunately, these racialized-gendered hierarchies continue to create divisions that separate Filipinx/a/o people and communities from seeing each other and working through these emotional triggers together. As seen through the fraught relationship between Ellen and Chico, we cannot continue colonial gender dynamics where one is purely consoling while the other is free to give into their rage.
Conclusion
For many of us who have witnessed and lived through Filipinx/a/o disputes at the dinner table we know that emotions can run high quickly. During the Christmas season, where we are forced to speak to one another and where old habits of criticism and Filipino scrutiny might arise, we at Stacey’s Peminist Corner encourage you to allow yourself the chance to step back, reflect, recognize, and empathize with the colonial legacies at play at the dinner table.
As seen through the relationship between Ellen and Chico, these racialized-gendered systems that are unique to the Filipinx/a/o community happen regularly throughout our day to day in both our public and private lives. What Filipinx/a/o person hasn’t seen a father figure have a random and explosive outburst that is disproportionate to the current circumstances, similar to Chico. What Filipinx/a/o person hasn’t seen a mother figure do damage control in response to said father figure’s random outburst, similar to Ellen. The holidays are not always easy for many of us living in the Filipinx diaspora still haunted by colonial masculinities. If you need space, do so. We support you. Leave the table, and come back if you can, and say your peace. These outbursts can be very personal, no doubt. However, they also reflect the ways in which neocolonial violence has forced many of our kapamilya to deal with their emotional triggers and traumas by themselves. How can we say our peace in ways that provide full breadth to our individual pain while still preserving networks of mutual aid and community healing in mind?
Thank you for sticking around for this blog post. We’ll be starting off where we left off: how and why do Filipinas/x continue to commit themselves to a complex dance of affective labor? How have Filipinas/x taken it upon themselves to cultural retool care work, not as a gendered obligation of care, but rather as a moment to rebuild and envision Filipinx/a/o home that speaks to kapwa and community care.
Ingat fellow readers and peminist wanderers.
#BabaeAko #LalabanAko #professorpinay #pinayjoy #pemnistthoughts #staceysmillenialcorner #PeministTeam ( ̄▽ ̄)ノ





Comments